Dan Dryden wrote:...The only problem I can see is that the pad swept area is 43.5mm.... 2.5mm larger than is available on my disc.... I wonder if 2.5mm could be shaved from the bottom of the pads?.... Also my discs are 8mm thick, the site recommends a minimum of 10mm....
I would think so. I have the opposite problem on my trike's front brake, it has a Harley rotor and an aftermarket caliper that uses Honda Goldwing pads which sweep slightly further outboard...as they wear, a lip develops on the outer edge of the pads that rides on the periphery of the rotor, making an annoying/embarrassing squeal that only stops when the brake's applied. To prevent that I have to grind some away from the pads.
As far as the rotor thickness goes, it shouldn't hurt anything other than you'll be needing to replace the pads a little more frequently. It's not uncommon for the same caliper to be used on different rotor widths in conjunction with pads of corresponding thickness - for example, the MKI GTI Rabbits had thicker, vented rotors than the "normal" Bunnies and used the exact same caliper but had thinner/harder pads; same situation with many Honda motorcycle models. If Hi Spec designed their calipers to accept a pad with an industry-standard conformation (quite likely I would think), there'd be a good chance that you can find a compatible one that's a little thicker.
Dan Dryden wrote:...I will look into another idea I had which involved using a steel hub from Pacific Parts and bolting a brake disc from another manufacturer with a suitably sized disc.
The Wilwood DPHA Honda setup I mentioned comes with 262mm bolt-on rotors (and there are slotted/drilled options available), with 4x100 PCD...doesn't look like the center would be quite big enough to redrill to 130mm:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/WILWOOD-DPHA-FR ... rmvSB=true
I found the 4-piston Honda calipers for sale separately, my guess as to cost was pretty good:
https://www.jhpusa.com/store/pc/viewPrd ... duct=12257
Several folks have said that they'd found other calipers which'd bolt directly to the VW spindles (been hoping one would chime in on this topic). IIRC, there are BMW, Volvo, and even Mopar-subcompact calipers which might bolt up, but I have no idea if any of those yields any better rim clearance.
Oh, and if someone should suggest trying the Girling calipers from a `74 'Ghia my advice would be to avoid them. Rare, prone to squealing, require oddball LH thread flex hose too IIRC)