Chip Birks wrote: ↑Sat Dec 24, 2022 11:49 am
Thanks for the video! What do you think the solution is? I had always thought that those cylinders were pretty much bullet proof. Back to aluminum?
,
Yeah, what to do now is the million dollar question..
I think establashing the root cause first is key. From what I have seen, they were fine new, so using them made them unround. Its an open door, but that leaves two possible causes and probably the participated both here: heat and pressure.
Allthough I did see signs that the cilinder pressure did do something as the cylinders were a bit wider in the middle in general then all the way top or bottom.
The ovality at all heights was worse though. The only conclusion then is that heat made them unround. Likely the resulting temperature gradient was too high, meaning some parts in the radius got (way) hotter then other parts of the cylinder, despite the nice and trick cooling system I run.
Unfortunately - and as much I hate to admit this - most alu cylinders I have run could not with stand the cylinder pressures unless you would sleeve them with the cylinder head opening (thats a sort of joke, but not entirely..) or so.
The very best alu cylinder sleeving is however a biral cylinder. When done properly, they are awesome for boost and cooling well imo.
My 98mm AA birals were still within 2/100 ovality after the 1 bar and 400hp turbo abuse, even though they just have a 3,5mm wall thickness. Thats half of the Deutz cylinder! Strangely the AA's had much more taper then the Deutz cylinders, but I guess that was probably build in the AA's (top being about 5/100 smaller then the bottom..)
Still not entirely sure what I'd do, but I speak to a few high end tuners in germany in 3 weeks (X-mas-winter indoor show in Herford), so lets see what they come up with. Thorsten hinted he could make me a 102 biral... that would be interesting..
to be continued.